Image
IMG_1172
Photo:

Mary and Martha were visited by Jesus, as told in Luke 10:38–42. I see in this story several insights that could inspire our reflection on ourselves as Christians and on ecumenical teaching and learning.

You know the story: While Mary sat at the Lord's feet and listened to his teaching, Martha was busy in the kitchen. Finally, she went to him and said, “Lord, do you not care that my sister has left me to serve alone? Tell her then to help me.” Jesus answered her, “Martha, Martha, you are anxious and troubled about many things; one thing is needful. Mary has chosen the good portion, which shall not be taken away from her.”

Isn’t serving an honorable task—especially for Christians? Isn’t it something to be commended when we devote ourselves to serving others? Yes, it is. And that is why there is absolutely nothing to criticize about Martha’s efforts. She is doing something good. She does it out of love and with love. Jesus and Mary benefit from it.

Hospitality is a commandment of God. Hospitality is faith put into practice! Genuine hospitality is a very important form of love of neighbour. So let us listen once again carefully to what Jesus says to Martha. He does not criticize her for working or for becoming stressed by what she is doing. He criticizes her for criticizing her sister.

Jesus refuses to establish a hierarchy between listening and working, between resting and doing, talking and working, receptivity and activity. Both have their rightful place – at their appropriate time. Jesus does not say: “Mary has chosen the better portion”, but: “She has chosen the good portion”. And I add: “here and now”. That is meant to acknowledge her behaviour against her sister’s complaints. Jesus does not make any judgment. He admonishes Martha to respect what her sister is doing. The good part—listening and talking – does not exclude but complements the other part: working.

Immediately before the story of Mary and Martha is told in the gospel of Luke, Jesus teaches us the parable of the Good Samaritan. Someone had asked Jesus what he had to do to inherit eternal life. And Jesus had urged him to put mercy into practice. He did not tell him to sit down and listen; he told him to do good. “Go and do likewise”—that is how the parable ends. Christians are encouraged to follow that role model into loving service.

Jesus challenges us both to serve and to be served even by people who may be regarded as outsiders. As you know, Samaritans were despised by many Jews at that time. In this case, Jesus does not say, “The Samaritan has chosen the good part.” No, here it becomes quite clear that serving those who are in need is required—regardless of their religious affiliation. 

The story of Mary and Martha teaches us that Christian faith consists of both listening and serving, worship and diakonia—each in its proper time. Both are necessary: working in accordance with the will of God, and also coming to rest so that we can listen attentively to the Word of God, being nourished and transformed by it time and again. To renew and deepen our discipleship, we must stop and listen. The Word is the one thing needful. Implanted in us, growing, and springing forth, it will bear fruit in loving action. Love of neighbor is subsequent to and dependent upon a love of the Lord that sits at his feet like Mary.

These two dimensions belong together, just as the sisters Mary and Martha belong together: contemplation and action, being spiritually nourished and physically feeding others. We should therefore not generally prefer one attitude to the other. Rather, Christian faith calls us to hold both together and to discern when each is needed. As we are told in Ecclesiastes 3,1: “For everything there is a season, and a time for every matter under heaven”.

The problem with Martha is not that she serves actively but that she is distracted, anxious, and troubled about many things. For all her hospitality and welcoming, Martha is just too busy—as the priest and the Levite were too busy to help the man who fell among thieves. Martha is too busy with her own priorities to pay impractical attention to someone who’s not giving her the help she thinks she needs, and not telling her sister to help her, either.

This story can give us something to take with us on our journey in our daily life: It shows us the importance of listening carefully not only to the Word of God but also to other people; listening to the nuances in want they communicate to us. Perhaps because, like Jesus, they see a path of suffering ahead of them. We need to listen with our hearts in order to understand what they do not say explicitly but nevertheless seek to convey. Listening to the quiet voices.

This story can give us something to take with us on our journey in Ecumenical teaching and learning. As you know quite well, Ecumenism divides its cooperative Christian unity efforts into two foundational streams: Life and Work and Faith and Order. Perhaps we could interpret that as the Martha-stream and the Mary-stream. They are sisters that need each other. Life and Work focuses on practical cooperation, social action, and addressing global human need. Faith and Order focusses on deepening and clarifying the spiritual and theological dimensions of Christian faith. It aims at overcoming historical divisions among the churches. Faith leads to practice and practice roots in faith. 

Ecumenical teaching and learning connect both dimensions. It has to begin ever anew by listening to the Word of God. This is the fundamental source of its inspiration and motivation. At the same time, it must remain attentive to the social, economic, and political contexts, be sensitive to ecological concerns, and listen to the quiet voices—especially those who, like Jesus, see a path of suffering lying ahead of them. It must practice not only physical but also epistemic hospitality, fostering genuine reciprocity. The voices of those who are silent or marginalised can make a significant contribution to reshaping and enriching theological knowledge.

But the story of Mary and Martha can also warn us against ecumenical hyper-activism and remind us that ecumenism is ultimately God’s work. We are servants in God’s project. We have a responsibility and a promise, but we are not the managers of the ecumenical movement. In the final instance, that task belongs to God.

At another point, Jesus says, “For even the Son of Man did not come to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many” (Mark 10:45). He is the “Servant King” who serves us at the Lord’s table. By “worship service,” we normally mean that Christians come together to serve God. But we could also understand the term in a different sense—not primarily as a service that we render to God, but as God’s service to us? We might think of it as the service of the Good Shepherd, who seeks to set us free from the compulsion to serve, from the pressure to perform, from constraints on our behaviour and thinking, and also from grief and despair about it. The Good Shepherd says to us: Less can be more. There are times when it is more important to come to rest, to listen attentively with our hearts to what God wants to say to us.

“Faith comes from hearing the message,” Paul writes (Romans 10:17)—from listening to what God wants to tell us, sometimes through the quiet voices that might otherwise go unheard. And then, faith leads to action. It is like breathing in and breathing out. Lutherans may place a somewhat stronger emphasis on listening to the Word, Reformed Christians on social action, Orthodox Christians on liturgy and so on. Yet all of these dimensions belong together. The Christian denominations are like branches of the Tree of Life. In it, we grow and flourish, and our very identity is bound up with this tree. In it we are one. The Tree of Life gives us life in such abundance that we can become a life-giving community ourselves. In this way, we participate in the Missio Dei—the mission of God—to heal the brokenness within Christianity and within the world.

Let us have a moment of silence together now, in which we can listen to the silent voices in us.

About the author :

Prof. em. Dr. Reinhold Bernhardt is Professor Emeritus of Systematic Theology and Dogmatics at the Faculty of Theology, University of Basel, Switzerland, where he served until January 2024. He is a member of the WCC Commission on Ecumenical Education and Formation.

Disclaimer

The impressions expressed in the blog posts are the contributions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinion or policies of the World Council of Churches.